At Melbourne pre-1950

Player	Seasons at Carlton	Seasons at Melbourne	Other Clubs
Jimmy Aitken	1897–1898	1898	Nil
Dan Lanigan	1899	1898	Collingwood
Artie McSpeerin	1899	1903	Nil
Harry Rigby	1900–1902	1907–1908	Nil
Fred Elliott	1900–1911	1899	Nil
Jack Gardiner	1901–1902	1903–1908	Nil
Tom Watson	1902	1904	Nil
Albert Gourlay	1904	1903	Nil
Les Abbott	1905	1912	Collingwood; South Melbourne; Richmond
Fred Hewitt	1905	1908–1910	Nil
George McCart	1905	1908	St Kilda
Bert Parke	1905, 1913	1907–1912	Nil
Jack Hammond	1906	1907	Nil
Andy Kennedy	1906	1908	Nil
Albert Bickford	1906–1907	1908–1909	Nil
Vin Gardiner	1907–1917	1905	Nil
Jack Baquie	1909–1913	1907–08, 14–20	Nil
Jack Bristow	1910	1912–1913	Richmond
Bruce Campbell	1911	1920	Fitzroy
Fen McDonald	1911–1912	1913	Nil
Charlie Taylor	1911	1906	St Kilda
Paddy Mills	1912–1913	1903–1909	Nil
Alf Williamson	1912–1914	1914	Nil
Vic Gordon	1915	1914	St Kilda
Bill Hore	1915–1919	1919	St Kilda
Jack Woolley	1918–1919	1914	Essendon
Alec Farrow	1922–1923	1919–1921	Nil
Harry Davie	1928	1924–1927	Nil
Jack Young	1932–1933	1934	Nil
Terry Ogden	1934	1932	Nil
Frank P Williams	1936–1937	1938–1941	Nil
Frank McGrath	1945	1944	Nil