At Melbourne post-1950

Player	Seasons at Carlton	Seasons at Melbourne	Other Clubs
Ken McKaige	1953–1954	1951–1952	Nil
Graham Kerr	1954–1955	1957	Nil
Keith Robinson	1956	1954	Nil
Kevin Clarke	1956–1959	1955	Nil
John Comben	1963–1966	1967	Nil
Tony Thiessen	1964	1963	North Melbourne (1965)
Ron Barassi	1965–1969	1953–1964	Nil
Peter McLean	1966–1968	1964–1965	Nil
Ken Jungwirth	1967	1966	Nil
Peter Smith	1968–1970	1966–1967	Nil
Brent Crosswell	1968–1975	1980–1982	North Melbourne
Phil Pinnell	1969–1979	1980–1981	Nil
Paul Hurst	1970–1974	1975–1977	Nil
Vin Catoggio	1973–1980	1981–1982	South Melbourne
Michael Young	1977–1980	1981–1982	Nil
Greg Wells	1980–1982	1969–1980	Nil
Peter Rohde	1985–1987	1988–1995	Nil
Paul Payne	1989	1985–1988	Nil
Earl Spalding	1992–1997	1987–1991	Nil
Andrew Leoncelli*	1993	1996–2003	Nil
Brent Heaver	1992–1996	1990–1991	Port Power
James Cook	1994–1995	2000	Bulldogs
Sean Charles	1998	1992–1997	St Kilda
Troy Longmuir	2005–2006	1998–1999	Fremantle
Chris Johnson	2009–2010	2005–2008	Nil
Brock McLean	2010–2014	2004–2009	Nil
Tomas Bugg*	2019	2016–2018	GWS Giants
Oscar McDonald	2021–2022	2015–2020	Fremantle

* Denotes players who did not play a senior game for Carlton.