From Glenelg, SA
From Blueseum - History of the Carlton Football Club
| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Stephen Kernahan | 1986 - 1997 | Celebrated Captain; 1987 and 1995 Premiership |
| David Kernahan | 1988 - 1993 | Brother of Stephen; 53 games, 8 goals |
| Andrew McKay | 1993 - 2003 | Carlton Captain; 1995 Premiership, Glenelg / Lucindale SA |
| Lindsay Smith | 2002 | From the Kangaroos / Bordertown, SA |
| Bryce Gibbs | 2007 - 2017 | Drafted in the 2006 National Draft #1 Draft Pick - Debuted in Round 1, 2007 - Plympton / Brighton HS |
| Mark Austin | 2007 - 2011 | Drafted in the 2006 National Draft #35 Draft Pick - Debuted in Round 22, 2007 / Brighton HS |
| Patrick McCarthy | 2011 - 2013 | Drafted in the 2010 National Draft #34 Draft Pick - Debuted in Round 23, 2012 - Plympton |
| Luke Parks | 2021 - 2022 | Drafted in the 2020 Rookie Draft #8 Draft Pick - Originally from St Ives (NSW) / Sydney Swans Academy |
| Sam Durdin | 2022 - 2024 | Glenelg / North Melbourne / West Adelaide / East Murray SA. |
| Ashton Moir | 2024 - ? | Glenelg / Plympton SA. |
| Lucas Camporeale | 2025 - ? | Glenelg / Brighton SA - Drafted at pick #43 in the 2024 National Draft. |
| Ben Camporeale * | 2025 - ? | Glenelg / Brighton SA - Drafted at pick #54 in the 2024 National Draft. |
